To test if the preparation of granular samples with flow pulses is
independent of the preparation history, we used the following
sequence of 1450 flow pulses: First the flow rate was
decreased in 14 steps from 60 mL/min to 23 mL/min (red curve), and
then increased again with the same 14 steps backwards (blue curve). Each
step consisted of 50 flow pulses, the volume fraction Φ was measured
after the sample had sedimented into a mechanically stable configuration.